Table of Contents
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Air Rower vs Magnetic Rower: Which One Should You Choose?
Air Rower vs Magnetic Rower, rowing machines are excellent fitness equipment that can provide a full-body workout, burn calories, and improve cardiovascular health. However, not all rowing machines are the same. Different rowing machines use different mechanisms to create resistance and simulate the rowing motion. Two of the most popular types are air rowers and magnetic rowers. In this article, we will approximate the features of air and magnetic rowers, their pros and cons, and help you decide which is best for you.
What is an Air Rower?
An air rower is a rowing machine that uses a fan flywheel to generate resistance. The fan flywheel is connected to a handle by a chain or a strap. When you pull the handle, you spin the fan flywheel, which creates air resistance. The faster you pull, the more additional resistance you get. This Air Rower means the resistance level is variable and depends on your rowing speed and intensity. Some air rowers also have a damper setting, which is a lever that controls the amount of air that enters the flywheel housing. By adjusting the damper setting, you can change the feel of the rowing stroke.
What is a Magnetic Rower?
A magnetic rower is a rowing machine that uses magnets and a solid steel flywheel to create resistance. The magnets are attached to a knob or a button that allows you to adjust the resistance level manually. The resistance level is fixed and does not change with your rowing speed or intensity. The magnetic rower is quiet and smooth, as no friction or air resistance is involved.
Air Rower vs Magnetic Rower: Pros and Cons
Air Rower Pros
- Air rowers are more realistic and natural, as they mimic the variable resistance and fluidity of water rowing.
- Air rowers are more challenging and dynamic as they respond to your rowing speed and intensity. This Air Rower makes them ideal for high-intensity interval training (HIIT) and competitive rowing.
- Air rowers have more accurate data readouts on the monitor as they measure the rower’s actual work. They also have more advanced features and functions, such as preset workouts, games, and online connectivity.
Air Rower Cons
- Air rowers are noisy, producing a whooshing sound with every stroke. Air rowers annoy some users and their neighbors, especially in small or crowded spaces.
- Air rowers are bulky and heavy, with a large fan flywheel and a long rail. They also require more space to operate and store, as they cannot be folded or tilted.
Magnetic Rower Pros
- Magnetic rowers are very quiet, as they do not have any air or friction resistance. This Magnetic Rower suits users who want a silent, peaceful workout or live in apartments or shared spaces.
- Magnetic rowers are more compact and lightweight, with a smaller flywheel and a shorter rail. They also take up less space and can be folded or tilted for easy storage.
Magnetic Rower Cons
- Magnetic rowers are less realistic and natural, as they do not replicate the variable resistance and fluidity of water rowing. They also have a more mechanical and artificial feel, as the resistance is constant and uniform.
- Magnetic rowers are less challenging and dynamic, as they do not respond to your rowing speed and intensity. This Magnetic Rower makes them less suitable for HIIT and competitive rowing. They also need more accurate data readouts on the monitor as they measure the estimated work done by the rower. They also need more features and functions, such as preset workouts, games, and online connectivity.
Conclusion
Air and magnetic rowers have advantages and disadvantages, depending on your personal preferences, goals, and budget. An air rower might be a better choice if you want a more realistic, challenging, and dynamic rowing experience. A magnetic rower might be a better choice if you are looking for a quiet, smooth, and compact rowing machine. Either way, rowing is a great exercise that can benefit your health and fitness. Happy rowing!
Which type of rower is best?
There is no definitive answer to which type of rower is best, as different rowing machines have different features, benefits, and drawbacks. Your best choice depends on your preferences, fitness goals, budget, and space. Here are some factors to consider when comparing the four main types of rowing machines: air, water, magnetic, and hydraulic.
- Air rowers use a fan flywheel to create resistance by blowing air. The faster you row, the more resistance you generate. Air rowers are suitable for high-intensity interval training (HIIT), realistic rowing experience, accurate data readouts, and challenging workouts. However, they are also noisy, large, and heavy and may require more maintenance.
- Water rowers use a water tank with paddles to create resistance by moving water. The more complicated and faster you row, the more resistance you feel. Water rowers are suitable for a natural rowing feel, smooth and quiet operation, variable resistance, and aesthetic design. However, they are also expensive, bulky, and heavy and may require water changes and cleaning.
- Magnetic rowers use magnets and a solid flywheel to create resistance by changing the magnetic field. The resistance is constant and does not depend on your speed. You can adjust the resistance level manually or digitally. Magnetic rowers are suitable for quiet and smooth operation, compact and foldable design, multiple resistance levels and programs, and customizable workouts. However, magnetic rowers are also less realistic, responsive, and accurate and may have lower weight capacity.
- Hydraulic rowers use hydraulic pistons to create resistance by compressing fluid or air. The resistance is constant and does not depend on your speed. You can adjust the resistance level by adjusting the position of the pistons. Hydraulic rowers are suitable for low prices, small size, accessible storage, and basic workouts. However, they are also less smooth, less comfortable, less durable, and may have limited features and data.
About Author
